Page 49 - World Journal of Laparoscopic Surgeons
P. 49

WJOLS



                                                                                            Posterior Rectus Sheath
























          Graph 6: Comparative morphology of the complete PRS: Ansari   Graph 7: Comparative distribution of mirror and nonmirror anatomy
          vs Rizk; WT: Whole-tendinous; MT: Musculo-tendinous; PT: Partly   of the PRS on the two sides of the body (Numbers indicate
          tendinous (upper part tendinous and lower part fascia-like thinned-  percentage)
          out); TO: Thinned out throughout; GA: Grossly attenuated with
          tendinous bands; (Numbers indicate percentage)
                                                              patients in the present study. With respect to the BMI of
                                                              the patients, the PRS extent was found to vary significantly
             It is being increasingly recognized that the termina-  and the short PRS tended to occur mainly in the over-
          tion of the PRS is usually gradual, but may occasionally be   weight/obese patients. To the best of our knowledge, there
          abrupt with formation of a well-defined arcuate line. 1,11,22    is no clinical report cited in the literature in this regard for
                          23
          Cunningham et al  reported a gradual thinning of the   our comparative assessment. Therefore, this phenomenon
          PRS with absence of the arcuate line in 10% of the human   (occurrence of shorter PRS in overweight/obese individu-
          cadavers (n = 19). The present study documented this   als) needs, in view of the very small number of patients
          phenomenon of attenuation in only 1.5% of the hernia   in this group, validation by a larger laparoscopic study.
          repairs (n = 68) or 7% of all complete PRS cases (Graph 6).  Recurrence after TEPP hernioplasty for the primary
                                                  1
             In a classic first laparoscopic study, Arregui  observed   inguinal hernia has come down markedly to 0.1 to 0.5%
          in 1997 that “In many dissections, we have also noticed   in recent years. 25,26  However, some recent studies have
          that this posterior fascial sheet is made up of more than   reported even 0% recurrence rate after primary laparo-
          one layer further supporting the idea that this is a continu-  scopic repair through the TEPP approach. 27-29  Present
          ation of the attenuated PRS…”. Later in 2001, Spitz and   study also did not record any instance of hernia recurrence
                 22
          Arregui  observed that “with the improved optics and   in the mean follow-up period of 33 months. Presently zero-
          magnification afforded by the laparoscope, we have seen,   recurrence rate is cherished by many TEPP surgeons, espe-
          as mentioned earlier, that the PRS continues in a variably   cially in surgical forums and live operative workshops.
          attenuated fashion below the arcuate line. We are also able   As it is evident also in the present study, identification of
          to see that the PRS is comprised of more than one layer   the variability of the structures is really important for the
          below the arcuate line.” Their observations supported the  success of the seamless laparoscopic hernia repair with
                               17
          findings of Anson et al.  In the present study, a double-  better outcomes. 1,30  We agree with Faure et al  that “the
                                                                                                     25
          layered PRS was seen in 50% of the PT category (n = 16)  requirement for a flawless knowledge of preperitoneal
          of the PRS only, resulting in its overall incidence of 11.8%.  anatomy and its variations” is essential for performing the
                                      24
             Colborn and Skandalakis  reported nonmirror  well-organized preperitoneal repair with ease and safety.
          anatomy of the PRS in about 30% of the cadaveric dissec-  Moreover, we now believe the prophetic Words of Spitz
                                                                         22
          tions. Present study documented nonmirror morphology  and Arregui  that “As comprehensive knowledge of the
          of the PRS in 37.5% of the hernia repairs, which is in tune  preperitoneal fascial anatomy becomes more widespread,
                                              24
          with that of the Colborn and Skandalakis ; however, the  there likely will be a broader application of the laparo-
          PRS extent in our study was nonmirror in a much higher  scopic preperitoneal hernia repair.”
                                        4
          percentage of 50% (Graph 7). Rizk  reported nonmirror   The present study has rather two limitations—one, the
          anatomy of the PRS in only 2.5% of cadavers, especially in  sample size is rather small, and second, there is absence
          terms of the PRS extent and the PRS morphology was found  of female patients in the study, because inguinal hernia
          similar on the two sides of the body even in these cases.  is one of the commonest surgical procedures in general
             The extent and/or morphology of the PRS did not vary  surgery and that the inguinal hernia is known to occur
          significantly with respect to the age or profession of the  in both sexes albeit rarely in females.
          World Journal of Laparoscopic Surgery, January-April 2018;11(1):12-24                             23
   44   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54